Рішення № 50147087, 08.09.2015, Апеляційний суд Одеської області

><5@ ?@>20465==O: 22-F/785/5963/15

>;>2CNG89 C ?5@HV9 V=AB0=FVW !_1

>?>2V40G !84>@5=:> . .

/& !# !, !"

(/

 # 

08.09.2015 @>:C <. 45A0

>;53VO AC44V2 AC4>2>W ?0;0B8 C F82V;L=8E A?@020E 0?5;OFV9=>3> AC4C 45AL:>W >1;0ABV 2 A:;04V: 3>;>2CNG>3> AC44V - !84>@5=:> .., AC44V2  >3>@T;>2>W !.., &N@8 ".., ?@8 A5:@5B0@V >;<0:>2V .., @>73;O=C2H8 C 2V4:@8B><C AC4>2><C 70AV40==V 0?5;OFV9=C A:0@3C !_2 =0 70>G=5 @VH5==O 0;8=>2AL:>3> @09>==>3> AC4C <. 45A8 2V4 05 ;8AB>?040 2014@. ?> A?@02V 70 ?>7>2>< !_3 4> !_4, !_2 ?@> CAC=5==O ?5@5H:>4 C :>@8ABC20==V 2;0A=VABN, 28A5;5==O B0 7=OBBO 7 @5TAB@0FV9=>3> >1;V:C, -

2AB0=>28;0:

09 25@5A=O 2014@. !_3 725@=C2AO 7 ?>7>2><, 2 O:><C ?@>A82 AC4 7>1>2O70B8 !_4 V !_2 CAC=CB8 ?5@5H:>48 C :>@8ABC20==V 2;0A=VABN H;OE>< 28A5;5==O 2 ?>@O4:C AB.116  #:@0W=8 2V4?>2V40GV2 V 7=OBBO 7 @5TAB@0FV9=>3> >1;V:C 2 :20@B8@V  !_1, ?>A8;0NG8AL =0 B5, I> 9><C =0 ?@02V 2;0A=>ABV 70 4>3>2>@>< :C?V2;V-?@>406C 2V4 13 G5@2=O 2014@. =0;568BL 28I52:070=0 :20@B8@0, 2 O:V9 157?V4AB02=> <5H:0NBL 2V4?>2V40GV.

0>G=8< @VH5==O< 0;8=>2AL:>3> @09>==>3> AC4C <. 45A8 2V4 05 ;8AB>?040 2014@. ?>7>2 !_3 704>2>;5=> (0.A.28-29).

!C4 7>1>2O702 !_4 V !_2 CAC=CB8 !_3 ?5@5H:>48 C :>@8ABC20==V 2;0A=VABN, 0 A0<5 :20@B8@>N  75 C 1C48=:C  46 ?> 2C;8FV :. $V;0B>20 C <. 45AV, H;OE>< 28A5;5==O !_4 V !_2 7 2:070=>W :20@B8@8 157 =040==O V=H>3> 68;>3> ?@8<VI5==O.

!C4 2AB0=>282 ?>@O4>: 28:>=0==O @VH5==O AC4C, 2V4?>2V4=> 4> O:>3> ?VA;O =01@0==O =8< 70:>==>W A8;8, F5 @VH5==O T ?V4AB02>N 4;O 0;8=>2AL:>3> @09>==>3> 2V44V;C C <. 45AV # ! #:@0W=8 2 45AL:V9 >1;0ABV 4;O 7=OBBO 7 @5TAB@0FV9=>3> >1;V:C !_4 V !_2 70 04@5A>N:  !_2. !C4 ABO3=C2 2 @V2=8E G0AB:0E 7V !_4 V !_2 =0 :>@8ABL !_3 AC4>289 71V@ 2 @>7<V@V 2433@=.60:>?.

#E20;>N AC4C 2V4 29 :2VB=O 2015@. !_4 V !_2 2V4<>2;5=> C 704>2>;5=V 70O28 ?@> ?5@53;O4 70>G=>3> @VH5==O AC4C (0.A.70-72).

 0?5;OFV9=V9 A:0@7V !_2 ?@>A8BL A:0AC20B8 @VH5==O AC4C, CE20;8B8 =>25 @VH5==O ?@> 2V4<>2C C 704>2>;5==V ?>7>2C !_3, ?>A8;0NG8AL =0 B5, I> @VH5==O AC4C ?5@H>W V=AB0=FVW T =570:>==8<, =5>1‘@C=B>20=8<, ?>AB0=>2;5=> 7 ?>@CH5==O< =>@< <0B5@V0;L=>3> V ?@>F5AC0;L=>3> ?@020 (0.A.89-90).

!?@020 @>73;O=CB0 C 2V4ACB=>ABV ?>7820G0 !_3, 2V4?>2V40G0 !_4, O:V 1C;8 =0;56=8< G8=>< A?>2VI5=V ?@> A;CE0==O A?@028.

>;53VO AC44V2, 70A;CE02 AC44N-4>?>2V40G0, ?@54AB02=8:0 !_2, 282G82H8 <0B5@V0;8 A?@028 2 <560E 4>2>4V2 0?5;OFV9=>W A:0@38, 22060T, I> 0?5;OFV9=0 A:0@30 ?V4;O30T 704>2>;5==N 7 =0ABC?=8E ?V4AB02.

!B0BB5N 213 & #:@0W=8 ?5@5410G5=>, I> @VH5==O AC4C ?>28==> 1CB8 70:>==8< V >1‘@C=B>20=8<.

3V4=> 7V AB.214 & #:@0W=8 ?V4 G0A CE20;5==O @VH5==O AC4 28@VHCT B0:V ?8B0==O: 1) G8 <0;8 <VAF5 >1AB028=8, O:8<8 >1‘@C=B>2C20;8AO 28<>38 V 70?5@5G5==O, B0 O:8<8 4>:070<8 2>=8 ?V4B25@46CNBLAO; 2)G8 T V=HV D0:B8G=V 40=V, O:V <0NBL 7=0G5==O 4;O 28@VH5==O A?@028, B0 4>:078 =0 WE ?V4B25@465==O; 3) O:V ?@02>2V4=>A8=8 AB>@V= 28?;820NBL V7 2AB0=>2;5=8E >1AB028=; 4) O:0 ?@02>20 =>@<0 ?V4;O30T 70AB>AC20==N 4> F8E ?@02>2V4=>A8=.

"0:8< 28<>30< 70:>=C 70>G=5 @VH5==O AC4C ?5@H>W V=AB0=FVW =5 2V4?>2V40T.

!C4>< 0?5;OFV9=>W V=AB0=FVW 2AB0=>2;5=>, I> !_3 70 4>3>2>@>< :C?V2;V-?@>406C 2V4 13 G5@2=O 2014@., =0;568BL :20@B8@0  !_1. >7820GC !_3 AB0;> 2V4><>, I> 2 :20@B8@V ?@>6820NBL B0 70@5TAB@>20=V !_4, !_2, O:8E 2V= ?@>A82 28A5;8B8 B0 7=OB8 7 @5TAB@0FVW.

04>2>;L=82H8 ?>7>2 !_3 ?@> 28A5;5==O B0 7=OBBO 7 @5TAB@0FVW ?>7820GV2, AC4 ?5@H>W V=AB0=FVW, O: =0 ?V4AB02C 704>2>;5==O ?>7>2C, 7@>182 ?>A8;0==O =0 28<>38 AB.AB.109,116  #:@0W=8, =0 28<>38 AB.AB.29, 316, 317, 321, 383, 391 & #:@0W=8.

"0:, G0AB8=>N 3 AB. 116  #:@0W=8 ?5@5410G5=>, I> >AV1, O:V A0<>?@02=> 709=O;8 68;5 ?@8<VI5==O, 28A5;ONBL 157 =040==O W< V=H>3> 68;>3> ?@8<VI5==O.

!B0BB5N 109 G.1  #:@0W=8 ?5@5410G5=>, I> 28A5;5==O V7 709<0=>3> 68;>3> ?@8<VI5==O 4>?CA:0TBLAO 7 ?V4AB02, CAB0=>2;5=8E 70:>=><. 8A5;5==O ?@>2>48BLAO 4>1@>2V;L=> 01> 2 AC4>2><C ?>@O4:C.

V4?>2V4=> 4> AB. 316 & #:@0W=8, ?@02> 2;0A=>ABV T ?@02> >A>18 =0 @VG (<09=>), O:5 2>=0 74V9A=NT 2V4?>2V4=> 4> 70:>=C 70 A2>TN 2>;5N, =570;56=> 2V4 2>;V V=H8E >AV1.

3V4=> V7 AB. 317 & #:@0W=8, 2;0A=8:>2V =0;560BL ?@020 2>;>4V==O, :>@8ABC20==O B0 @>7?>@O465==O A2>W< <09=><. 0 7<VAB ?@020 2;0A=>ABV =5 2?;820NBL <VAF5 ?@>6820==O 2;0A=8:0 B0 <VAF57=0E>465==O <09=0. V4?>2V4=> 4> AB. 321 & #:@0W=8, ?@02> 2;0A=>ABV T =5?>@CH=8<. VEB> =5 <>65 1CB8 ?@>B8?@02=> ?>7102;5=89 FL>3> ?@020 G8 >1<565=89 C 9>3> 74V9A=5==V. !B0B5N AB. 383 & #:@0W=8 2AB0=>2;5=>, I> 2;0A=8: :20@B8@8 <0T ?@02> 28:>@8AB>2C20B8 ?><5H:0==O 4;O 2;0A=>3> ?@>6820==O.

V4?>2V4=> 4> AB. 391 & #:@0W=8, 2;0A=8: <09=0 <0T ?@02> 28<030B8 CAC=5==O ?5@5H:>4 C 74V9A=5==V =8< ?@020 :>@8ABC20==O B0 @>7?>@O465==O A2>W< <09=><.

V4?>2V4=> 4> 2AB0=>2;5=>3> AB.11 & #:@0W=8 ?@8=F8?C 48A?>78B82=>ABV F82V;L=>3> AC4>G8=AB20 AC4 @>73;O40T F82V;L=V A?@028 =5 V=0:H5 O: 70 725@=5==O< DV78G=8E G8 N@848G=8E >AV1, ?>40=8< 2V4?>2V4=> 4> FL>3> :>45:AC, 2 <560E 70O2;5=8E =8<8 28<>3 V =0 ?V4AB02V 4>:07V2 AB>@V= B0 V=H8E >AV1, O:V 15@CBL CG0ABL C A?@02V. A>10, O:0 15@5 CG0ABL C A?@02V, @>7?>@O460TBLAO A2>W<8 ?@020<8 I>4> ?@54<5B0 A?>@C =0 2;0A=89 @>7AC4.

>7820G5< 1C;8 70O2;5=V 28<>38 ?@> 28A5;5==O 2V4?>2V40GV2 7 =0;56=>W 9><C =0 ?@02V 2;0A=>ABV :20@B8@8 =0 ?V4AB02V AB.AB.116  #:@0W=8, AB.AB.317, 319, 321, 386, 391 & #:@0W=8.

!C4 ?5@H>W V=AB0=FVW =5 CB>G=82 C ?>7820G0 ?V4AB028, 7 O:8E 1C;8 70O2;5=V ?>7>2=V 28<>38, =5 2@0EC202, I> ?8B0==O, ?>2O70=V 7 28<>30<8 ?@> 28A5;5==O 7 ?@8<VI5==O =0;56=>3> 2;0A=8:C, @53C;NNBLAO =V AB.116  #:@0W=8.

>73;O=C2H8 A?@02C C 70>G=><C ?>@O4:C, AC4 =5 A?>2VAB82 =0;56=8< G8=>< 2V4?>2V40GV2 ?@> A;CE0==O A?@028 =0 05 ;8AB>?040 2014@., I> ?V4B25@46CTBLAO <0B5@V0;0<8 A?@028 7 0.A.22-25, 0 0:B =0 0.A.22, 2 B><C 283;O4V O: 2V= A:;045=89, ?@> =0<030==O 2@CG8B8 AC4>2V ?>2VAB:8 2V4?>2V40G0< =V T =0;56=8< A?>2VI5==O< ?@> A;CE0==O A?@028.

!C4>< ?5@H>W V=AB0=FVW 27030;V =5 1C;8 2AB0=>2;5=V >1AB028=8, ?>2O70=V 7 ?@>6820==O< 2V4?>2V40GV2 2 A?V@=V9 :20@B8@V, B0 =5 ?@89=OB> 4> C2038, I> @VH5==O< 0;8=>2AL:>3> @09>==>3> AC4C <. 45A8 2V4 28 B@02=O 2013@. ?>?5@54=L><C 2;0A=8:C :20@B8@8 1C;> 2V4<>2;5=> C 704>2>;5=V ?>7>2C ?@> 28A5;5==O 2V4?>2V40GV2 7 2:070=>W :20@B8@8 (0.A.50-53).

V4?>2V4=> 4> AB.309 & #:@0W=8 ?V4AB020<8 4;O A:0AC20==O @VH5==O AC4C T, 7>:@5<0, =5?@028;L=5 70AB>AC20==O =>@< <0B5@V0;L=>3> 01> ?@>F5AC0;L=>3> ?@020.

!B0BB5N 60 & #:@0W=8 2AB0=>2;5=>, I> :>6=0 AB>@>=0 7>1>2O70=0 4>25AB8 BV >1AB028=8, =0 O:V 2>=0 ?>A8;0TBLAO O: =0 ?V4AB02C A2>WE 28<>3 V 70?5@5G5=L. 3V4=> G.1 AB.11 & #:@0W=8 AC4 @>73;O40T A?@028 2 <560E 70O2;5=8E 28<>3 B0 =0 ?V4AB02V =040=8E AB>@>=0<8 4>:07V2.

>7820G =5 =0402 AC4C ?5@H>W V=AB0=FVW B0 0?5;OFV9=>W V=AB0=FVW =0;56=8E B0 4>?CAB8<8E 4>:07V2 =0 ?V4B25@465==O A2>WE ?>7>2=8E 28<>3.

>7820G !_3 =5 ?>7102;5=89 <>6;82>ABV 725@=CB8AO 4> AC4C 7V 70E8AB>< A2>WE ?@02, CB>G=82H8 A2>W ?>7>2=V 28<>38 2V4?>2V4=> 4> 28<>3 70:>=C.

5@CNG8AL AB.AB. 303, 304, 307, 316, 317, 319 & #:@0W=8, :>;53VO AC44V2

28@VH8;0:

?5;OFV9=C A:0@3C !_2  704>2>;L=8B8.

0>G=5 @VH5==O 0;8=>2AL:>3> @09>==>3> AC4C <. 45A8 2V4 05 ;8AB>?040 2014@. A:0AC20B8, CE20;8B8 =>25 @VH5==O.

# 704>2>;5==V ?>7>2C !_3 4> !_4, !_2 ?@> CAC=5==O ?5@5H:>4 C :>@8ABC20==V 2;0A=VABN, 28A5;5==O B0 7=OBBO 7 @5TAB@0FV9=>3> >1;V:C - 2V4<>28B8.

VH5==O 0?5;OFV9=>3> AC4C =018@0T 70:>==>W A8;8 7 <><5=BC ?@>3>;>H5==O.

0A0FV9=0 A:0@30 <>65 1CB8 ?>40=0 ?@>BO3>< 4204FOB8 4=V2 7 4=O =01@0==O 70:>==>W A8;8 @VH5==O< 0?5;OFV9=>3> AC4C H;OE>< ?>40GV :0A0FV9=>W A:0@38 157?>A5@54=L> 4> AC4C :0A0FV9=>W V=AB0=FVW.

>;>2CNG89: ..!84>@5=:>

!C44V: !.. >3>@T;>20

!_5