Court ruling № 81755907, 11.05.2019, Commercial Court of Khmelnytskyi Oblast

! !, !# %,&, !"

29000, <. %<5;L=8FL:89, <0940= 570;56=>ABV, 1 B5;. 71-81-84, D0:A 71-81-98

_____________

# %    

"11" B@02=O 2019 @.!?@020  4/5025/1097/12

>A?>40@AL:89 AC4 %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV C A:;04V 3>;>2CNG>3> AC44V @0<GC:0 .. ?@8 A5:@5B0@V 07V9 .. @>73;O=C2H8 C 2V4:@8B><C AC4>2><C 70AV40==V <0B5@V0;8 A?@028, ?>@CH5=>W

0 70O2>N ?@820B=>3> ?V4?@8T<AB20 "V45@" <. 0;CH, 20=>-$@0=:V2AL:0 >1;0ABL

          ?@> 10=:@CBAB2> B>20@8AB20 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" A. >20 !8=O2:0

                                         !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV

0 CG0ABN ?>2=>206=8E ?@54AB02=8:8 CG0A=8:V2 :

70O2=8:0 : =5 28:;8:0;8AL

:@548B>@8 : =5 28:;8:0;8AL

1>@6=8:0 : !_1  48@5:B>@ - =5 28:;8:02AO

;V:2V40B>@  !_2  0@1VB@06=89 :5@CNG89 =5 28:;8:02AO

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

>7?>@O465==O< :5@V2=8:0 0?0@0BC AC4C  319/13 2V4 "13" B@02=O 2013@. )>4> ?@87=0G5==O ?>2B>@=>3> 02B><0B8G=>3> @>7?>4V;C A?@02 7 >3;O4C =0 2V4?CAB:C AC44V B0 ?@89=OBBO 5@E>2=>N 04>N #:@0W=8 ?>AB0=>28  214-VII 2V4 18.04.2013@. ?@> 72V;L=5==O !_4 7 ?>A048 AC44V 3>A?>40@AL:>3> AC4C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV 2V4?>2V4=> 4> ?C=:BC 3.1.13 >;>65==O ?@> 02B><0B87>20=C A8AB5<C 4>:C<5=B>>1V3C AC4C ?@87=0G5=> ?>2B>@=89 02B><0B8G=89 @>7?>4V; A?@028  4/5025/1097/12 2 =0A;V4>: O:>3> A?@02C ?5@540=> =0 @>73;O4 AC44V @0<GC:C .., 0 B><C >AB0==N ?@89=OB> 4> ?@>20465==O 7 ?@87=0G5==O< =0 AB04VW ?>?5@54=L>3> 70AV40==O.

>AB0=>2>N C A?@02V 2V4 23 3@C4=O 2015@. B>20@8AB2> 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" (N@848G=0 04@5A0 : 2C;. .$@0=:0, 9 A. >20 !8=O2:0 !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV, V4.:>4 32987356) 287=0=> 10=:@CB>< V7 2V4:@8BBO< ;V:2V40FV9=>W ?@>F54C@8 C A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12 AB@>:>< 4> 23 :2VB=O 2016@. B0 ?@87=0G5==O< ;V:2V40B>@>< " "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" (N@848G=0 04@5A0 : 2C;. .$@0=:0, 9 A. >20 !8=O2:0 !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV, V4.:>4 32987356) C A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12 0@1VB@06=>3> :5@CNG>3> !_2 (2C;. >=B8, 68, <. %<5;L=8FL:89, #:@0W=0, 29011, V45=B8DV:0FV9=89 =><5@  _1; !2V4>FB2>  565 2V4 18.03.2013@.; E-mail 2458418914@mail.gov.ua). >40B:>2> AC4 ?>AB0=>282 >?@8;N4=8B8 =0 >DVFV9=><C 251-A09BV 8I>3> 3>A?>40@AL:>3> AC4C #:@0W=8 >3>;>H5==O (?>2V4><;5==O) ?@> 287=0==O 10=:@CB>< ">20@8AB20 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" (N@848G=0 04@5A0 : 2C;. .$@0=:0, 9 A. >20 !8=O2:0 !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV, V4.:>4 32987356), V 2V4:@8BBO ;V:2V40FV9=>W ?@>F54C@8 C A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12. !B@>: 28:>=0==O 2AVE 3@>H>28E 7>1>2O70=L ">20@8AB20 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" (N@848G=0 04@5A0 : 2C;. .$@0=:0, 9 A. >20 !8=O2:0 !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV, V4.:>4 32987356), 22060B8 B0:8<, I> =0AB02 23.12.2015@., 0 B0:>6 ?@8?8=5=> 7 23.12.2015@. =0@0EC20==O =5CAB>9:8 (HB@0DC, ?5=V), 2V4A>B:V2 B0 V=H8E 5:>=><VG=8E A0=:FV9 70 2AV<0 7>1>2'O70==O<8 ">20@8AB20 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" (N@848G=0 04@5A0 : 2C;. .$@0=:0, 9 A. >20 !8=O2:0 !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV, V4.:>4 32987356), O: 10=:@CB0. :@V< B>3> ?@8?8=5=> 7 23.12.2015@. ?>2=>2065==O >@30=V2 C?@02;V==O ">20@8AB20 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" (N@848G=0 04@5A0 : 2C;. .$@0=:0, 9 A. >20 !8=O2:0 !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV, V4.:>4 32987356), O: 10=:@CB0 I>4> C?@02;V==O 10=:@CB>< B0 @>7?>@O465==O 9>3> <09=>< V7 ?@8?8=5==O< ?>2=>2065=L 2;0A=8:0 (2;0A=8:V2) <09=0 10=:@CB0. !:0A>20=> 0@5HB8, =0:;045=V =0 <09=> 1>@6=8:0 - ">20@8AB20 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" (N@848G=0 04@5A0 : 2C;. .$@0=:0, 9 A. >20 !8=O2:0 !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV, V4.:>4 32987356), B0 V=HV >1<565==O I>4> @>7?>@O465==O <09=>< 1>@6=8:0. 0:;045==O =>28E 0@5HBV2 01> V=H8E >1<565=L I>4> @>7?>@O465==O <09=>< 10=:@CB0 =5 4>?CA:0TBLAO.

&VTN 6 ?>AB0=>2>N 7>1>2O70=> ;V:2V40B>@0 :

- 28:>@8AB>2C20B8 BV;L:8 >48= 10=:V2AL:89 @0EC=>: 4;O 70@0EC20==O :>HBV2, >B@8<0=8E ?V4 G0A ?@>2545==O ;V:2V40FV9=>W ?@>F54C@8 B0 4;O 74V9A=5==O @>7@0EC=:V2 7 :@548B>@0<8 10=:@CB0. =HV @0EC=:8, 28O2;5=V ?@8 ?@>2545==V ;V:2V40FV9=>W ?@>F54C@8, ?V4;O30NBL 70:@8BBN ;

- ?@>25AB8 ;V:2V40FV9=C ?@>F54C@C 10=:@CB0 2V4?>2V4=> 4> 28<>3 0:>=C #:@0W=8 "@> 2V4=>2;5==O ?;0B>A?@><>6=>ABV 1>@6=8:0 01> 287=0==O 9>3> 10=:@CB><", A:;0AB8 ;V:2V40FV9=89 10;0=A B0 ?>40B8 9>3> 3>A?>40@AL:><C AC4C @07>< V7 72VB>< ?@> A2>N 4VO;L=VABL C AB@>: 4> 23.04.2016@.;

- ?8AL<>2> =04020B8 AC4C >48= @07 =0 <VAOFL 72VB ?@> EV4 ;V:2V40FV9=>W ?@>F54C@8 7 2V4?>2V4=8< 4>:C<5=B0;L=8< ?V4B25@465==O, 2V4><>ABV ?@> DV=0=A>25 AB0=>28I5 B0 <09=> 1>@6=8:0, 70?;0=>20=V 70E>48 I>4> ?@>406C <09=0 1>@6=8:0.

- ?8AL<>2> =04020B8 AC4C >48= @07 =0 <VAOFL 72VB ?@> EV4 ;V:2V40FV9=>W ?@>F54C@8 7 2V4?>2V4=8< 4>:C<5=B0;L=8< ?V4B25@465==O, 2V4><>ABV ?@> DV=0=A>25 AB0=>28I5 B0 <09=> 1>@6=8:0, 70?;0=>20=V 70E>48 I>4> ?@>406C <09=0 1>@6=8:0.

:@V< B>3> C <560E A?@028 CE20;>N AC4C 2V4 14 3@C4=O 2017 @>:C 70<V=5=> :@548B>@0 C A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12  %<5;L=8FL:5 >1;0A=5 2V44V;5==O $>=4C A>FV0;L=>3> AB@0EC20==O 7 B8<G0A>2>W 2B@0B8 ?@0F5740B=>ABV C !B0@>:>ABO=B8=VAL:><C @09>=V =0 ?@02>=0ABC?=8:0 - #?@02;V==O 28:>=02G>W 48@5:FVW $>=4C A>FV0;L=>3> AB@0EC20==O #:@0W=8 2 %<5;L=8FL:V9 >1;0ABV (:>4 41316723, <. %<5;L=8FL:89, 2C;. @>A:C@V2AL:0,18) 7 3@>H>28<8 28<>30<8 =0 AC<C 478 988,85 3@=.

#E20;>N AC4C 2V4 27.02.2017@. 70O2C >;>2=>3> C?@02;V==O $! C %<5;L=8FL:V9 (2E.  05-08/156/18 2V4 26.02.18) ?@> 70<V=C :@548B>@0 C A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12 704>2>;5=>. 0<V=5=> :@548B>@0 C A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12 @0A8;V2AL:C >1'T4=0=C 45@602=C ?>40B:>2C V=A?5:FVN >;>2=>3> C?@02;V==O $! C %<5;L=8FL:V9 >1;0ABV =0 >;>2=5 C?@02;V==O $! C %<5;L=8FL:V9 >1;0ABV (:>4 39492190).

#E20;>N AC4C 2V4 19.07.2018@. 70O2C ( 15453/08 2V4 25.05.2018@) >;>2=>3> C?@02;V==O 5=AV9=>3> D>=4C #:@0W=8 2 %<5;L=8FL:V9 >1;0ABV ?> A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12 704>2>;5=>. 0<V=5=> :@548B>@0 C A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12 C?@02;V==O 5=AV9=>3> D>=4C #:@0W=8 2 !B0@>A8=O2AL:><C @09>=V %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV (:>4 06952470) =0 >;>2=5 C?@02;V==O 5=AV9=>3> D>=4C #:@0W=8 2 %<5;L=8FL:V9 >1;0ABV (:>4 21318350).

#E20;>N AC4C 2V4 12.03.2019@. ?@>4>265=> B5@<V= ;V:2V40FV9=>W ?@>F54C@8 C A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12 ?@> 10=:@CBAB2> ">20@8AB20 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" (N@848G=0 04@5A0: 2C;..$@0=:0,9 A.>20 !8=O2:0 !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV, V4.:>4 32987356) 4> 23.05.2019 @>:C.

10.05.2019@. 0@1VB@06=89 :5@CNG89 - ;V:2V40B>@ !_2 ?>402 72VB-:;>?>B0==O (2E.05-06/265/19 2V4 10.05.2019@.) ?@> ?@>4>265==O AB@>:C ;V:2V40FV9=>W ?@>F54C@8 " "!8=O2AB:V 3@0=VB8" =0 B@8 <VAOFV, O:C =5>1EV4=> ?@87=0G8B8 4> @>73;O4C.

5@CNG8AL AB. AB. 24, 32 0:>=C #:@0W=8 "@> 2V4=>2;5==O ?;0B>A?@><>6=>ABV 1>@6=8:0 01> 287=0==O 9>3> 10=:@CB><, AB.AB. 54, 234  #:@0W=8, AC4 -

# E 2 0 ; 8 2:

>73;O4 72VBC-:;>?>B0==O (2E.05-06/265/19 2V4 10.05.2019@.) 0@1VB@06=>3> :5@CNG>3> - ;V:2V40B>@0 !_2 ?@> ?@>4>265==O AB@>:C ;V:2V40FV9=>W ?@>F54C@8 " "!8=O2AB:V 3@0=VB8" =0 B@8 <VAOFV C A?@02V  4/5025/1097/12 ?@> 10=:@CBAB2> B>20@8AB20 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "!8=O2AL:V 3@0=VB8" A.>20 !8=O2:0 !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> @09>=C ?@87=0G8B8 =0 09:30 3>4. "16" B@02=O 2019 @.

0AV40==O 2V41C45BLAO 2 ?@8<VI5==V 3>A?>40@AL:>3> AC4C %<5;L=8FL:>W >1;0ABV 70 04@5A>N: <. %<5;L=8FL:89, 0940= 570;56=>ABV, 1.

87=0B8 O2:C ?>2=>206=8E ?@54AB02=8:V2 :><VB5BC :@548B>@V2, 1>@6=8:0 B0 ;V:2V40B>@0 >1>2O7:>2>N.

!C44O                                                                                                    @0<GC: ..

V44@C:>20=> 29 ?@8<V@=8:V2: 1 - 4> A?@028, 2-V=VFVNNG><C :@548B>@C ?@820B=><C ?V4?@8T<AB2C "V45@"  !_1,; 3-1>@6=8:C 31433,%<5;L=8FL:0 >1;. !B0@>A8=O2AL:89 @-=, A. >20 !8=O2:0, 2C;. .$@0=:0, 9; 4 - $>=4C A>FV0;L=>3> AB@0EC20==O 7 B8<G0A>2>W 2B@0B8 ?@0F5740B=>ABV 2 >A>1V 28:>=02G>W 48@5:FVW %<5;L=8FL:>3> >1;0A=>3> 2V44V;5==O (<. %<5;L=8FL:89 2C;. @>A:C@V2AL:0,18); 5-6B>20@8AB2C 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "@0=VB @C?" <. !0=:B-5B5@1C@3", 2C;. V>=5@AL:0,22 :2.15;?@54AB02=8: !_5 <.=V?@>475@68=AL:, 2C;. @>EV4=89 BC?8:, 1C4.10,>DVA), 7-8 @" 1>;>=L (N@848G=0 04@5A0:04655, <.8W2, 2C;.>30B8@AL:0,3; ?>HB>20 04@5A0:31600 A<B '5<5@V2FV, 2C;. 1''W7=0,3) ; 9- " ..". # (01054,<. 8W2, 2C;. >=G0@0,33, >D.1); 10-#?@02;V==N 5=AV9=>3> D>=4C #:@0W=8 2 !B0@>A8=O2AL:><C @09>=V (A<B. !B0@0 !8=O20, 2C;. .$@0=:0,8), 11-V44V;5==N  $!! C !B0@>:>ABO=B8=V2AL:><C @09>=V (<. !B0@>:>ABO=B8=V2, 2C;.AB@>7L:>3>,43), 12-!B0@>A8=O2AL:><C @09>==><C F5=B@C 709=OB>ABV A<B.!B0@0 !8=O20 2C;..$@0=:0,7, 13-@0A8;V2AL:0 <V6@09>==045@602=2 ?>40B:>20 V=A?5:FVO 2 >A>1V !B0@>A8=O2AL:>3> 2V44V;5==O (A<B. !B0@0 !8=O20 2C;..$@0=:0,50), 14- " "$V@<0"8W2C=V25@A0;?;NA" 02094,<.8W2, 2C;.'5@2>=>B:0FL:0,29-0, 15- " "3@0@=89 :><5@FV9=89 10=:" 03150, <.8W2, 2C;.8<8B@>20,9, 16-5@602=><C ?V4?@8T<AB2C "0C:>2>-28@>1=8G><C >1'T4=0==N "02;>3@04AL:89 EV<VG=89 702>4" 51402,=V?@>?5B@>2AL:0 >1;0ABL, <.02;>3@04,2C;. 02>4AL:0,44, 17- " ""5@0",07300, 8W2AL:0 >1;0ABL, <.8H3H>@>4, 2C;.@><8A;>20,4, 18- " ""5E=>5:A?>@B", 07400, 8W2AL:0 >1;0ABL, <.@>20@8, 2C;.8W2AL:0,290, 19- " ">=BC@" 308015, >AV9AL:0 $545@0FVO, <.T;3>@>4, 2C;.>ABL>=AL:0,3-,20- " "!>N7:><?;5:B0FVO", 300028, >AV9AL:0 $545@0FVO, <."C;0, 2C;. 9 0O 1.16, 21-" "040-"@0AB" 125315, >AV9AL:0 $545@0FVO, <.>A:20, 2C;.'0A>20,28, :>@?.4,:V<=.1-3, 22- " "5;LB00=:" 04080,<.8W2, 2C;.$@C=75,39, 23-" "#:@B5E?@><;V78=3", 01001, <.8W2, 2C;.@8=8=AL:0,5/24, 24-5@602=5 ?V4?@8T<AB2> "5@602=89 575@2=89 =0AV==T289 D>=4 #:@0W=8",03038 <.8W2 2C;./<AL:0,32, 25- ;V:2V40B>@C !_2,29011 <. %<5;L=8FL:89, 2C;.>=B8 ,68, 26-3>;>2=><C C?@02;V==N NAB8FVW C %<5;L=8FL:V9 >1;0ABV 27- 3>;>2=><C C?@02;V==N 5=AV9=>3> D>=4C #:@0W=8 C %<5;L=8FL:V9 >1;0ABV <.%<5;L=8FL:89 2C;.5@F5=0,10; 28-29-">20@8AB2C 7 >1<565=>N 2V4?>2V40;L=VABN "9VA #:@0W=0" (:>4 42682150, ?>HB>20 04@5A0: 03164, 8W2-164, 0/A 4; 04210, <.8W2, ?@-B 5@>W2 !B0;V=3@04C, 1C4.2, >DVA 111)

2AV< @5:><. 7 ?>2V4><;. ?@> 2@CG.