Court ruling № 50185313, 22.12.2014, Commercial Court of Odesa Oblast

! !, !# !, !"

_______________________

#%

"22" 3@C4=O 2014 @. 916/3408/13

0 ?>7>2><: 45AL:>W <VAL:>W @048;

70 CG0ABN B@5BL>W >A>18, O:0 =5 70O2;OT A0<>ABV9=8E 28<>3 =0 ?@54<5B A?>@C =0 AB>@>=V ?>7820G0: 5?0@B0<5=BC :><C=0;L=>W 2;0A=>ABV 45AL:>W <VAL:>W @048;

4> 2V4?>2V40GV2: 1) C1;VG=>3> 0:FV>=5@=>3> B>20@8AB20 :><5@FV9=89 10=: "@820B0=:";

2) $V78G=>W >A>18-?V4?@8T<FO !_1;

3) =A?5:FVW 7 ?8B0=L 70E8ABC ?@02 A?>6820GV2 2 45AL:V9 >1;0ABV;

4) C1;VG=>3> 0:FV>=5@=>3> B>20@8AB20 " 0=:" $V=0=A8 B0 @548B" 2 >A>1V DV;VW "45AL:5 @53V>=0;L=5 C?@02;V==O " " 0=:" $V=0=A8 B0 @548B";

70 CG0ABN B@5BVE >AV1, O:V =5 70O2;ONBL A0<>ABV9=8E 28<>3 =0 ?@54<5B A?>@C =0 AB>@>=V 2V4?>2V40GV2: 1) 5@H>3> 0;8=>2AL:>3> ! 45AL:>3> <VAL:>3> C?@02;V==O NAB8FVW;

2) @C3>3> 8W2AL:>3> ! 45AL:>3> <VAL:>3> C?@02;V==O NAB8FVW;

3) @C3>3> @8<>@AL:>3> 2V44V;C 45@602=>W 28:>=02G>W A;C618 45AL:>3> <VAL:>3> C?@02;V==O NAB8FVW;

?@> 287=0==O ?@020 2;0A=>ABV B0 7=OBBO 0@5HBV2

>;>2CNG89 AC44O )028=AL:0 ...

!C44O !B5?0=>20 ..

!C44O (0@0B>2 ...

!#", ! #:  ?@>20465==V :>;53VW AC44V2 C A:;04V: 3>;>2CNG89 AC44O )028=AL:0 ..., AC44O !B5?0=>20 .., AC44O (0@0B>2 ... ?5@51C20;0 A?@020 916/3408/13 70 ?>7>2>< 45AL:>W <VAL:>W @048, 70 CG0ABN B@5BL>W >A>18, O:0 =5 70O2;OT A0<>ABV9=8E 28<>3 =0 ?@54<5B A?>@C =0 AB>@>=V ?>7820G0, 5?0@B0<5=BC :><C=0;L=>W 2;0A=>ABV 45AL:>W <VAL:>W @048 4> C1;VG=>3> 0:FV>=5@=>3> B>20@8AB20 :><5@FV9=89 10=: "@820B0=:", $V78G=>W >A>18-?V4?@8T<FO !_1, =A?5:FVW 7 ?8B0=L 70E8ABC ?@02 A?>6820GV2 2 45AL:V9 >1;0ABV, C1;VG=>3> 0:FV>=5@=>3> B>20@8AB20 "0=:" $V=0=A8 B0 @548B" 2 >A>1V DV;VW "45AL:5 @53V>=0;L=5 C?@02;V==O " "0=:" $V=0=A8 B0 @548B", 70 CG0ABN B@5BVE >AV1, O:V =5 70O2;ONBL A0<>ABV9=8E 28<>3 =0 ?@54<5B A?>@C =0 AB>@>=V 2V4?>2V40GV2: 5@H>3> 0;8=>2AL:>3> ! 45AL:>3> <VAL:>3> C?@02;V==O NAB8FVW, @C3>3> 8W2AL:>3> ! 45AL:>3> <VAL:>3> C?@02;V==O NAB8FVW, @C3>3> @8<>@AL:>3> 2V44V;C 45@602=>W 28:>=02G>W A;C618 45AL:>3> <VAL:>3> C?@02;V==O NAB8FVW, 2 O:><C ?>7820G ?@>A82 AC4 287=0B8 70 B5@8B>@V0;L=>N 3@><04>N <. 45A8 2 >A>1V 45AL:>W <VAL:>W @048 ?@02> 2;0A=>ABV =0 =568;V ?V420;L=V ?@8<VI5==O, 7030;L=>N ?;>I5N 92,0 :2.<, I> @>7B0H>20=V 70 04@5A>N: <. 45A0, 2C;. L20 ">;AB>3>, 13.; 7=OB8 0@5HB, =0:;045=89 =0 =568;V ?V420;L=V ?@8<VI5==O, 7030;L=>N ?;>I5N 92,0 :2.<, I> @>7B0H>20=V 70 04@5A>N: <. 45A0, 2C;. L20 ">;AB>3>, 13, ?>AB0=>2>N ?@> =0:;045==O 0@5HBC A5@VW  168313 2V4 20.12.2010@. 28=5A5=>N 5@602=8< 28:>=02F5< @C3>3> 8W2AL:>3> 2V44V;C 45@602=>W 28:>=02G>W A;C618 45AL:>3> #. !_2 (>1BO65==O 10632522); 7=OB8 0@5HB, =0:;045=89 =0 =568;V ?V420;L=V ?@8<VI5==O, 7030;L=>N ?;>I5N 92,0 :2.<, I> @>7B0H>20=V 70 04@5A>N: <. 45A0, 2C;. L20 ">;AB>3>, 13, ?>AB0=>2>N ?@> 0@5HB <09=0 1>@6=8:0 B0 >3>;>H5==O 701>@>=8 =0 9>3> 2V4GC65==O  632884 2V4 21.06.2010 @., 28=5A5=>N 5@602=8< 28:>=02F5< 5@H>3> 0;8=>2AL:>3> ! 45AL:>3> #. !_3 (>1BO65==O  9955377); 7=OB8 0@5HB, =0:;045=89 =0 =568;V ?V420;L=V ?@8<VI5==O, 7030;L=>N ?;>I5N 92,0 :2.<, I> @>7B0H>20=V 70 04@5A>N: <. 45A0, 2C;. L20 ">;AB>3>, 13, ?>AB0=>2>N ?@> 0@5HB <09=0 1>@6=8:0 B0 >3>;>H5==O 701>@>=8 =0 9>3> 2V4GC65==O 2V4 16.06.2011@. 27106778, 28=5A5=>N 45@602=8< 28:>=02F5< 5@H>3> 0;8=>2AL:>3> ! 45AL:>3> #. !_3 (>1BO65==O  11293097); 7=OB8 0@5HB, =0:;045=89 =0 =568;V ?V420;L=V ?@8<VI5==O, 7030;L=>N ?;>I5N 92 :2.<., I> @>7B0H>20=V 70 04@5A>N: <. 45A0, 2C;. L20 ">;AB>3>, 13, ?>AB0=>2>N ?@> 0@5HB <09=0 1>@6=8:0 B0 >3>;>H5==O 701>@>=8 =0 9>3> 2V4GC65==O 2V4 05.09.2011@. 27654715, 28=5A5=>N 45@602=8< 28:>=02F5< @C3>3> @8<>@AL:>3> ! 45AL:>3> #. !_4 (>1BO65==O 11604480); 7=OB8 0@5HB, =0:;045=89 =0 =568;V ?V420;L=V ?@8<VI5==O, 7030;L=>N ?;>I5N 92,0 :2.<, I> @>7B0H>20=V 70 04@5A>N: <. 45A0, 2C;. L20 ">;AB>3>, 13, ?>AB0=>2>N ?@> 0@5HB <09=0 1>@6=8:0 B0 >3>;>H5==O 701>@>=8 =0 9>3> 2V4GC65==O 2V4 12.10.2011@. 28675504, 28=5A5=>N 5@602=8< 28:>=02F5< 5@H>3> 0;8=>2AL:>3> ! 45AL:>3> #. !_5 (>1BO65==O 11716815); 7=OB8 0@5HB, =0:;045=89 =0 =568;V ?V420;L=V ?@8<VI5==O, 7030;L=>N ?;>I5N 92,0 :2.<, I> @>7B0H>20=V 70 04@5A>N: <. 45A0, 2C;. L20 ">;AB>3>, 13, ?>AB0=>2>N ?@> 0@5HB <09=0 1>@6=8:0 B0 >3>;>H5==O 701>@>=8 =0 9>3> 2V4GC65==O 2V4 14.09.2011@. 29077177, 28=5A5=>N 5@602=8< 28:>=02F5< 5@H>3> 0;8=>2AL:>3> ! 45AL:>3> #. !_6 (>1BO65==O  13205725).

V4?>2V4=> 4> ?. 3 AB. 57 >A?>40@AL:>3> ?@>F5AC0;L=>3> :>45:AC #:@0W=8 4> ?>7>2=>W 70O28 4>40NBLAO 4>:C<5=B8, O:V ?V4B25@46CNBL A?;0BC AC4>2>3> 71>@C C 2AB0=>2;5=8E ?>@O4:C V @>7<V@V.

>@O4>: A?;0B8 AC4>2>3> 71>@C B0 9>3> @>7<V@ ?5@5410G5=V 0:>=>< #:@0W=8 "@> AC4>289 71V@" 2V4 08.07.2011 @.  3674-V.

3V4=> 4> G.1. AB.4 0:>=C #:@0W=8 "@> AC4>289 71V@" AC4>289 71V@ A?@02;OTBLAO C 2V4?>2V4=><C @>7<V@V 2V4 <V=V<0;L=>W 70@>1VB=>W ?;0B8 C <VAOG=><C @>7<V@V, 2AB0=>2;5=>W 70:>=>< =0 1 AVG=O :0;5=40@=>3> @>:C, 2 O:><C 2V4?>2V4=0 70O20 01> A:0@30 ?>40TBLAO 4> AC4C, - C 2V4A>B:>2><C A?V22V4=>H5==V 4> FV=8 ?>7>2C B0 C DV:A>20=><C @>7<V@V.

@8 FL><C, ?C=:B>< 3 AB0BBV 6 0:>=C #:@0W=8 "@> AC4>289 71V@" 2AB0=>2;5=>, I> 70 ?>40==O ?>7>2=>W 70O28, I> <0T >4=>G0A=> <09=>289 V =5<09=>289 E0@0:B5@, AC4>289 71V@ A?;0GCTBLAO 70 AB02:0<8, 2AB0=>2;5=8<8 4;O ?>7>2=8E 70O2 <09=>2>3> B0 =5<09=>2>3> E0@0:B5@C.

@V< B>3>, 2V4?>2V4=> 4> ?. 2.11. ?>AB0=>28 ;5=C<C 8I>3> 3>A?>40@AL:>3> AC4C #:@0W=8 "@> 45O:V ?8B0==O ?@0:B8:8 70AB>AC20==O @>74V;C VI >A?>40@AL:>3> ?@>F5AC0;L=>3> :>45:AC #:@0W=8" 2V4 21 ;NB>3> 2013 @>:C N 7 2AB0=>2;5=>, I> O:I> 2 ?>7>2=V9 70O2V >1T4=0=> 42V 01> 1V;LH5 28<>3 =5<09=>2>3> E0@0:B5@C, ?>2O70=8E <V6 A>1>N ?V4AB020<8 28=8:=5==O 01> ?>40=8<8 4>:070<8, AC4>289 71V@ A?;0GCTBLAO >:@5<> 7 :>6=>W 7 B0:8E 28<>3.

/: 210G0TBLAO 7 ?@>E0;L=>W G0AB8=8 70O28 ?@> 7<V=C ?@54<5BC ?>7>2C, ?>7820G5< 70O2;5=> >4=C 28<>3C <09=>2>3> E0@0:B5@C B0 HVABL 28<>3 =5<09=>2>3> E0@0:B5@C.

0B><VABL, O: 210G0TBLAO 7 4>40=8E 4> ?>7>2=>W 70O28 4>:C<5=BV2, 70 ?>40GC ?>7>2=>W 70O28 ?>7820G5< A?;0G5=> AC4>289 71V@ 70 >4=C <09=>2C 28<>3C B0 AV< =5<09=>28E 28<>3 =0 7030;L=C AC<C 13 417,01 3@=.

V4?>2V4=> 4> G. 1 ?. 1 AB. 7 0:>=C #:@0W=8 "@> AC4>289 71V@" A?;0G5=0 AC<0 AC4>2>3> 71>@C ?>25@B0TBLAO 70 CE20;>N AC4C 2 @07V 7<5=H5==O @>7<V@C ?>7>2=8E 28<>3 01> 2=5A5==O AC4>2>3> 71>@C 2 1V;LH><C @>7<V@V, =V6 2AB0=>2;5=> 70:>=><.

@0E>2CNG8 70O2;5=89 ?>7820G5< @>7<V@ ?>7>2=8E 28<>3, AC4 4>E>48BL 4> 28A=>2:C I>4> =0O2=>ABV ?V4AB02 4;O ?>25@=5==O =04<V@=> A?;0G5=>3> AC4>2>3> 71>@C 70 >4=C =5<09=>2C 28<>3C C @>7<V@V 1 218 3@=., ?5@5@0E>20=>3> 70 ?;0BV6=8< 4>@CG5==O< 683 2V4 11.08.2014@.

5@CNG8AL AB. 86  #:@0W=8, AB.7 0:>=C #:@0W=8 "@> AC4>289 71V@", AC4 

#%:

1. >25@=CB8 7 5@602=>3> 1N465BC #:@0W=8 G5@57 >;>2=5 C?@02;V==O 5@602=>W :07=0G59AL:>W A;C618 #:@0W=8 2 45AL:V9 >1;0ABV (<VAF57=0E>465==O: <. 45A0, 2C;. !04>20, 10, :>4  # 37607526) =0 :>@8ABL 45AL:>W <VAL:>W @048 (65004, <. 45A0, ?;. C<AL:0, 1, :>4  # 26597691) AC4>289 71V@ C AC<V 1 218 />4=0 B8AOG0 42VABV 2VAV<=04FOBL/ 3@=., ?5@5@0E>20=89 70 ?;0BV6=8< 4>@CG5==O< 4>@CG5==O< 683 2V4 11.08.2014@.

>;>2CNG89 AC44O ... )028=AL:0

!C44O !B5?0=>20 ..

!C44O (0@0B>2 ...