Court ruling № 50183604, 18.08.2015, Dobropillia City and District Court of Donetsk Oblast

18.08.2015 227/4626/15-F

#%­­

?@> 2V4­:@8B­BO ?@>­20­465=­=O

18 A5@?­=O 2015 @>­:C <.>1­@>­?V;­;O

!C4­4O >1­@>­?V;L­AL­:>­3> <VAL:­@0­9>=­=>­3> AC­4C >­=5­FL:>W >1­;0A­BV %>­<5=­:> .., @>7­3;O­=C2­H8 ?>­7>2­=C 70O­2C " «" >1­@>­?V;­;O­2C­3V;­;O» DV­;VO «#?@02­;V=­=O :>­<C­=0;L­=8E :>­B5­;5=L» 4> !_1, ?@> ABO3­=5=­=O 70­1>@­3>­20­=>­ABV ?> A?;0­BV 68B­;>­2>-:>­<C­=0;L­=8E ?>A­;C3 7 F5=­B@0;L­=>­3> >?0­;5=­=O,-

!"­­:

>­78­20G 725@­=C2­AO 4> AC­4C V7 70­7=0­G5­=>N ?>­7>2­=>N 70O­2>N.

@8­9<0N­G8 4> C20­38, I> ?>­7>2­=0 70O­20 ?V4­AC4­=0 <VA­F5­2>­<C AC­4C B0 2V4­?>­2V­40T 28­<>­30< AB.AB.119-120 &8­2V;L­=>­3> ?@>­F5­AC­0;L­=>­3> :>­45:­AC, AC4 220­60T 70 <>6­;8­25 2V4­:@8­B8 ?@>­20­465=­=O C A?@0­2V 157 ?@>­25­45=­=O ?>­?5­@54­=L>­3> 70­AV­40=­=O B0 ?@8­7=0­G8­B8 A?@0­2C 4> AC­4>­2>­3> @>7­3;O­4C.

0 ?V4­AB0­2V 28­:;0­45­=>­3>, :5­@CN­G8AL AB.AB.122,130,210 & #:­@0­W­=8, AC4,-

#%­­:

V4­:@8­B8 ?@>­20­465=­=O C F8­2V;L­=V9 A?@0­2V 70 ?>­7>­2>< " «" >1­@>­?V;­;O­2C­3V;­;O» DV­;VO «#?@02­;V=­=O :>­<C­=0;L­=8E :>­B5­;5=L» 4> !_1, ?@> ABO3­=5=­=O 70­1>@­3>­20­=>­ABV ?> A?;0­BV 68B­;>­2>-:>­<C­=0;L­=8E ?>A­;C3 7 F5=­B@0;L­=>­3> >?0­;5=­=O.

>7­3;O4 A?@0­28 ?@8­7=0­G8­B8 =0 01 6>2B­=O 2015 @>­:C > 11:003>4., 2 ?@8­<V­I5=­=V AC­4C, 2 O:5 28­:;8­:0­B8 CG0A­=8­:V2 ?@>­F5­AC.

0­4VA­;0­B8 ?>­78­20­GC :>­?VN 40­=>W CE­20­;8, 0 2V4­?>­2V­40­GC :>­?VN CE­20­;8 B0 :>­?VN ?>­7>2­=>W 70O­28 7 4>­40B­:0­<8.

>7OA=8B8, I> 2V4­?>­2V4­=> 4> AB.128 & #:­@0­W­=8 2V4­?>­2V­40G C @0­7V 70­?5­@5­G5=­=O ?@>­B8 ?>­7>­2C ?>2­=V­ABN 01> G0­AB­:>­2> <0T ?@0­2> ?>­40­B8 ?8AL­<>­2V 70­?5­@5­G5=­=O, ?>­A8­;0N­G8AL =0 =5­70­:>=­=VABL 28­<>3 ?>­78­20­G0, V7 70­7=0­G5=­=O< 4>­:0­7V2, I> ?V4­B25@­46C­NBL 9>­3> 70­?5­@5­G5=­=O 4> ?>­G0B­:C @>7­3;O­4C A?@0­28 ?> AC­BV. "0­:>6, 73V4­=> AB.123 & #:­@0­W­=8 2V4­?>­2V­40G <0T ?@0­2> ?@54O28B8 7C­AB­@VG­=89 ?>­7>2 4> ?>­G0B­:C @>7­3;O­4C A?@0­28 ?> AC­BV.

>7OA=8B8 AB>­@>­=0<, I> 2V4­?>­2V4­=> 4> AB. 131 & #:­@0­W­=8 2>­=8 7>­1>2O70=V ?>­40­B8 A2>W 4>­:0­78 AC­4C 4> ?>­G0B­:C @>7­3;O­4C A?@0­28 ?> AC­BV. >­:0­78, ?>­40­=V 7 ?>­@C­H5=­=O< 28­<>3 2AB0­=>2­;5­=8E FV­TN AB0B­B5N =5 ?@8­9<0­N­BL­AO, O:­I> AB>­@>­=0 =5 4>­25­45, I> 4>­:0­78 ?>­40­=> =5­A2>T­G0A­=> 7 ?>­206­=8E ?@8­G8=.

!B>­@>­=8 4> ?>­G0B­:C @>7­3;O­4C A?@0­28 ?> AC­BV 7>­1>2O70=V ?>­2V­4>­<8­B8 AC4 ?@> 2AV 2V­4>­<V W< @V­H5=­=O AC­4V2, I> AB>­AC­N­BL­AO ?@54­<5­BC A?>­@C, 0 B0­:>6 ?@> 2AV 2V­4>­<V W< =5­70­25@­H5­=V AC­4>­2V ?@>­20­465=­=O, I> AB>­AC­N­BL­AO ?@54­<5­BC A?>­@C.

V­H5=­=O AC­4C =0­18­@0T 70­:>=­=>W A8­;8 ?V­A;O 70­:V=­G5=­=O AB@>­:C 4;O ?>­40=­=O 0?5­;O­FV9­=>W A:0@­38, O:­I> 0?5­;O­FV9­=C A:0@­3C =5 1C­;> ?>­40­=>. # @0­7V ?>­40=­=O 0?5­;O­FV9­=>W A:0@­38 @V­H5=­=O, O:­I> 9>­3> =5 A:0­A>­20­=>, =0­18­@0T 70­:>=­=>W A8­;8 ?V­A;O @>7­3;O­4C A?@0­28 0?5­;O­FV9­=8< AC­4><.

#E­20­;0 AC­4C <>­65 1C­B8 >A­:0@­65­=0 ;8­H5 7 ?@8­2>­4C =5­4>B­@8­<0=­=O ?@0­28; ?V4­AC4­=>­ABV H;O­E>< ?>­40=­=O 0?5­;O­FV9­=>W A:0@­38 4> 0?5­;O­FV9­=>­3> AC­4C >­=5­FL:>W >1­;0A­BV G5­@57 >1­@>­?V;L­AL:89 <VAL:­@0­9>=­=89 AC4 >­=5­FL:>W >1­;0A­BV ?@>­BO­3>< ?OB8 4=V2 7 4=O >B­@8­<0=­=O :>­?VW CE­20­;8.

 V=­HV9 G0A­B8­=V CE­20­;0 >A­:0@­65=­=N =5 ?V4­;O­30T.

!C4­4O .. %>­<5=­:>